Compare medicated dandruff shampoo actives — ketoconazole, selenium sulfide, zinc pyrithione, coal tar and salicylic acid — and find what suits you.

Dandruff is a mild, extremely common form of seborrhoeic dermatitis — an inflammatory scalp condition that causes white or yellowish flakes and, often, itching. It is not a sign of poor hygiene. The main driver is a yeast called Malassezia, which lives naturally on everyone's skin. In people prone to dandruff, this yeast feeds on the oils (sebum) produced by the scalp and triggers irritation and faster shedding of skin cells, which clump together as visible flakes.
Because oil is part of the picture, dandruff is usually associated with an oily rather than a dry scalp — a common misconception. Flaking tends to be worse in people with naturally oily skin, and it often flares with stress, cold or dry weather, hormonal changes and infrequent hair washing. Seborrhoeic dermatitis can also affect other oily areas such as the eyebrows, sides of the nose and ears. Understanding this is useful, because it explains why an antifungal medicated shampoo works better than simply moisturising or washing more gently.
Medicated anti-dandruff shampoos are sold over the counter in Australian pharmacies and supermarkets, and the active ingredient matters more than the brand on the bottle. Most work in one of two ways: they reduce the Malassezia yeast, they slow the shedding of skin cells, or they help lift existing scale. The table below compares the main actives you will see on Australian labels.
| Active ingredient | How it works | Best for | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ketoconazole (e.g. Nizoral) | Antifungal — reduces the Malassezia yeast | Stubborn dandruff and seborrhoeic dermatitis | The 1% shampoo is sold in supermarkets and pharmacies; higher strengths are pharmacist-only. Often used twice weekly. |
| Selenium sulfide (e.g. Selsun) | Antifungal and slows skin-cell turnover | Moderate to stubborn, flaky, itchy dandruff | Effective but can have a slight odour and may discolour bleached, grey or dyed hair. Rinse thoroughly. |
| Zinc pyrithione (e.g. Head & Shoulders) | Antifungal and antibacterial | Mild to moderate, everyday flaking | Widely available and gentle enough for frequent use. A common first step for milder dandruff. |
| Coal tar (e.g. Neutrogena T/Gel) | Slows the rate skin cells grow and shed | Flaky, scaly scalps and scalp psoriasis | Can have a distinctive smell, may stain light hair and can increase sun sensitivity of the scalp. |
| Salicylic acid | Keratolytic — loosens and lifts scale | Thick, built-up scale and flakes | Clears existing scale but does not target yeast; often combined with an antifungal active. |
| Piroctone olamine | Antifungal — reduces Malassezia yeast | A gentler alternative for sensitive scalps | A newer addition to anti-dandruff shampoos; a useful option if other actives irritate your scalp. |
If you have light flaking with little or no itch, start with a zinc pyrithione shampoo, which is gentle enough for regular use and widely available in Australian supermarkets and pharmacies. Use it as your everyday shampoo a few times a week. Many people find this is all they need to keep mild dandruff under control. If it is not helping after a few weeks of consistent use, it is reasonable to step up to a stronger antifungal active or ask your pharmacist for advice.
For persistent flaking, noticeable itch, redness, or dandruff that keeps coming back, a ketoconazole or selenium sulfide shampoo is usually more effective, because both have strong antifungal action against Malassezia. Seborrhoeic dermatitis — the more pronounced end of the dandruff spectrum — tends to respond best to these. If thick scale has built up, a salicylic acid shampoo can help lift it, sometimes used alongside an antifungal. Rotating between two different actives is a strategy some people use to stop the scalp adjusting, though there is no need to overcomplicate it if one product is working.
Anti-dandruff shampoos often disappoint simply because they are used like an ordinary shampoo — lathered and rinsed straight off. The active ingredient needs contact time on the scalp to work. Getting the technique right makes a bigger difference than switching brands.
Dandruff is not caused by poor hygiene, and scrubbing harder will not fix it — aggressive washing can irritate the scalp and make flaking worse. Nor is dandruff usually a dry-scalp problem, so piling on rich oils or heavy conditioners can sometimes feed the yeast rather than help. A few simple habits support whatever medicated shampoo you use.
The most reliable approach is a medicated anti-dandruff shampoo bought over the counter from a supermarket or pharmacy — no prescription is needed for standard strengths. Choose one with an antifungal active such as ketoconazole, selenium sulfide or zinc pyrithione, massage it into the scalp, leave it on for the labelled time (usually two to five minutes), and use it regularly until the flaking settles. You can then taper to a maintenance wash once or twice a week. If several weeks of correct use does not help, ask your pharmacist or GP.
For most people, a medicated shampoo containing an antifungal active is the most effective option, because it targets the Malassezia yeast that drives flaking. Ketoconazole and selenium sulfide tend to be the strongest performers for stubborn or seborrhoeic dermatitis-related dandruff, while zinc pyrithione suits milder cases. There is no single best product for everyone — the most effective treatment is the active ingredient that matches how stubborn your dandruff is and that your scalp tolerates well, used correctly and consistently.
Not permanently. Dandruff is a chronic, manageable condition rather than something that can be resolved for good, because the Malassezia yeast behind it lives naturally on everyone's scalp. A medicated shampoo can control the flaking and itch very effectively, but symptoms usually return if you stop treatment altogether. The realistic goal is long-term control: treat actively until your scalp settles, then keep it in check with regular maintenance washes.
No treatment clears dandruff overnight, but an antifungal medicated shampoo used correctly is the quickest route to visible improvement. The key is contact time — leaving the shampoo on the scalp for the full labelled duration rather than rinsing it straight off — and using it several times a week at first. Many people notice a meaningful reduction in flaking within one to two weeks of consistent use. If you want fast improvement, focus on technique and consistency rather than searching for a stronger product.
Everyday dandruff and seborrhoeic dermatitis are strongly linked to the Malassezia yeast, so most common dandruff already has a fungal component — which is why antifungal shampoos work. A practical clue is how it responds: flaking that improves with an antifungal active such as ketoconazole or selenium sulfide fits the usual yeast-driven pattern. Flaking that comes with thick silvery scale, well-defined red patches, intense itch, weeping or hair loss may point to another condition such as scalp psoriasis or a true fungal infection, and is worth having assessed by a pharmacist or GP.
Neither, in most cases. Dandruff is not a sign of being unclean — it is driven by the Malassezia yeast interacting with the natural oils on your scalp, so it is actually more common with an oily scalp than a dry one. Washing too rarely can let oil build up and make it worse, but scrubbing harder is not the answer and can irritate the skin further. Treating dandruff as a dry scalp by adding heavy oils can sometimes feed the yeast, which is why a medicated anti-dandruff shampoo is the better approach.
This information is general in nature and isn’t a substitute for professional medical advice. Always read the label and follow the directions for use. Talk to your pharmacist or doctor about what’s right for you.

Compare eczema creams sold in Australia: daily moisturisers, over-the-counter hydrocortisone for flares and bath oils — plus how to choose the right one.
Hydrocortisone cream may help relieve itching and inflammation from mild eczema, bites and rashes. Compare Sigmacort, DermAid and generic options in Australia.

Manage mild plaque psoriasis at home with heavy moisturisers, coal tar and salicylic acid — plus the red flags that mean it is time to see a GP.